EDH - Reward Point

Sheldon Menery a lancé une idée d'un système de points de "fun" pour les parties Commander. Le but étant de favoriser l'interaction et les play intéressants* plutôt que le kill rapide (1v1 style) ou le contrôle assomant (mono bleu).

The footnote includes how points can be awarded :

(M) = Each player can get this award any number of times.
(P) = Each player can get this award only once.
(1) = This award is available to one player only, and only once.

Negative points may not be awarded due to an opponent's actions. This is new, and Michael says that it's the only way to make “Too Many Options!” work. The list changes slightly from week-to-week. This is the full list from Week 3.

-4 Points (M): But We Just Started – Eliminating a player prior to their 5th turn.
-2 Points (M): Chasm – Be the instigator of wrecking one or more players mana bases, in part or in full. This includes spells like Armageddon, Bust, etc.
-2 Points (M): I Want To Play Too – “Mindslaver” a player for the 2nd + time.
-1 Points (M): Greedy McGreederson – Taking your 3rd+ consecutive turn.
-1 Point (M): Get on with it! – Take a turn of 6 minutes or more.
-1 Point (M): Something New? – Play the same spell for the 3rd+ time in the game. Your General doesn't count.
-1 Point (M): Too many options! – Draw or add a total of 10 additional cards to your hand in one turn.

+1 Point (P): Off the Top! – End the game or be eliminated having searched your library for no card besides a basic land.
+1 Point (P): I Like Land! – End the game or be eliminated having put no extra lands into play under your control.
+1 Point (1): So Much To Look Forward To – Be eliminated with the highest life total immediately before elimination.
+1 Point (P): Flow of Ideas – Control 3 or more permanents with chainable names (e.g. Sword of Fire and Ice, Ice Cauldron, Cauldron of Souls).
+1 Point (P): Block Party – Have a non-land permanent in play or spell present on the stack from each set of a block. Three consecutive Core sets with set symbols also counts for this award.
+1 Point (P): SOLVED! – Destroy or Exile an opponent's Maze of Ith, Maze of Shadows, Mystifying Maze, or Pravh, Spires of Order.
+1 Point (P): Start with the Top – Destroy or Exile a Sensei's Divining Top you don't control.
+1 Points (P): I Got This – Eliminate an opponent during another opponents turn.
+1 Points (M): You're Outta Here – Kill a player or being directly responsible for a player's elimination.
+1 Point (P): Generalissimo – Eliminate a player with General damage.
+1 Point (1): You're Still in This – Prevent a player from being eliminated from the game.
+1 Point (1): I'm Out – Be the first player eliminated from the table.
+2 Points (P): Get There – Play your General for the Fifth time from the Command Zone.


Qu'en pense Emilien, Nico and zo voort ?
Je trouve l'idée intéressante, mais faudrait modifier cette liste à notre sauce.


*Notez qu'un Warp World, je trouve ce play ultra chiant.

c'est pas vraiment nouveau en fait. alors j'ai déjà eu le tps d'y penser.
à la base, j'ai adoré l'idée. mais ça semble super compliqué à mettre en pratique. y'a déjà tellement de trucs à prendre en compte, que perso, je crains de ne plus avoir de neurones dispo pour repérer que je controle dragon broodmother, mother of runes et runes of the deus. déjà que j'ai bien du mal à me rappeler de lancer le dé quand on joue planechase.
enfin ce système de bonus n'a d'interet que dans le cadre d'un tournoi ou d'une ligue, ce qu'on ne pratique pas (pour le moment?)

C'est pour quoi je proposais de fabriquer notre propre petite liste et éviter les points style "block" ...

Nico Truc a écrit:c'est pas vraiment nouveau en fait.

Yep. Déjà lu ça depuis des plombes.
Ça n'a pas vraiment d'intérêt dans le cadre de la simple partie jouée sur un coin de table. Déjà qu'on se moque de savoir qui gagne, alors compter des points à la fin...