[Résolu] Question : Hideaway

J'ai encore une question : que se passe-t-il si on détruit un terrain non basique Hideaway ? Qu'advient-il de la carte cachée ?

> what happens after a hideaway land is destroyed, the key point being if the player is still able to look at
> the removed card.


The FAQ is correct that once the land leaves play, no one can look at
the removed card. The reasoning is a bit tricky though.

Because Hideaway says "any player who has controlled this land", the
list of players who may look can't be determined when the activated
ability resolves. Instead, we must evaluate who has previously
controlled the land when they try to do so and, in effect, we treat
this CE in the same was as one generated by a static ability (although
it's not). As with static abilities, we can't use LKI -- so if it's
not in play, no one can look at it.

Quirky... and certainly not a precedent for any other ruling... but in
this case, that's how it works.

--
Gavin Duggan, L3 Calgary: MTGRULES-L Netrep

Merci !

Moi j'ai une question encore plus debile, mais je suis soudaint prit d'un doute:
Je declanche l'habilite du land: "you may play the removed card without paying it's casting cost". Comme c'est "play", c'est contrable?

oui

merci

Bon Xav, stage intensif de magic à ton retour hein :p

Ouais, vais clairement en avoir besoin hehe

Tache de ne pas faire trop le boulet en 2HG!! Vieille daube